Can tomato paste be substituted for tomato purée?

Andrew Grimm
  • Can tomato paste be substituted for tomato purée? Andrew Grimm

    A recipe for meat loaf from an Australian book (apparently terminology differs from country to country) calls for 1 cup (250 mL/8 fl oz) of tomato purée, and 2 tablespoons of tomato sauce.

    Wikipedia's article on tomato purée claims that the main difference between purée and paste is the thickness, whereas tomato sauce has a different taste.

    Can I substitute tomato paste for the tomato purée? If not, is it because the taste, or the amount of water, differs?

    If so, how much "triple concentrated" tomato paste should be substituted for a cup of tomato purée?

    Edit: the tomato paste ingredients are: concentrated tomato (98%), salt. Link to the product page.

  • I think of tomato sauce as the plain stuff in the cans, and marinara as the seasoned red sauce served on many Italian pasta dishes. But many people use the terms interchangeably it seems, and even many authentic Italian restaurants list tomato sauce on their menus where it's actually the delicious seasoned stuff.

    I'm guessing that the Wikipedia article referring to sauce as having a different taste than puree and paste uses tomato sauce in the seasoned sense, like marinara, not the plain-stuff-in-cans sense. If that makes sense...

    As to the tomato paste vs. puree, the paste will be thicker and more concentrated in flavor and texture/composition. If you're looking for the closest consistency and flavor to puree to duplicate a recipe, you might start with about 2/1 ratio of puree/paste and tweak from there. If it were me just cooking on the fly like usual, I'd use the paste straight across (but seasoned with fresh herbs) for the more intense flavor, and back it down as and if necessary.

  • I'll weigh in on this one, having extensive cooking experience on both sides of the pond. The terminology is indeed confusing when it comes to tomato products. By tomato sauce they don't mean canned tomato sauce like you get in the states, they actually mean ketchup! As for puree there's two types, one is just what it means, pureed tomatoes in a can, and the other is super-concentrated like what in the US is called tomato paste and comes in a tube.

    Given it's this recipe is asking for 250ml of puree they must mean the canned stuff, as adding that much concentrate would be hideous. To replicate UK/AU style tomato puree I'd use a can of tomato sauce with a half mini-can of tomato paste to thicken it up a bit. That still sounds like a bit too much liquid for my taste.

    Alternatively you can use my mom's technique and add a can of concentrated tomato soup to the mix, it makes a great meat-loaf!

Tags
Related questions and answers
  • typically for pasta or pizza. marinara (US) is used synonymously with tomato sauce, and may refer to both quick or long-cooked varieties. tomato paste (US) is tomato purée (UK) tomato purée (US...), Scallions (US), and green onions may not always be the same thing, but can typically be substituted for each other. (more details). Herbs, Spices & Seasonings: Kosher(ing) salt (US) is flaked... on a griddle with a ring form. Scone (US, CA) tends to be sweeter than a scone (UK). Pancake (US, CA) Pikelet (AU) generally refers to puffy item made from a thick leavened batter. Pancake can go

  • Possible Duplicate: How do I convert between the various measurements? How to convert a cup to SI units? In otherwords, how many liters (or deciliters) one cup is?

  • Possible Duplicate: Over-stirring muffin mixtures From here: http://culinaryarts.about.com/od/bakingdesserts/r/plainmuffins.htm The key to making great muffins is not overmixing the batter. Once the liquid ingredients are added to the dry, mix the batter by hand just until the flour is moistened, for no more than about ten seconds. Too much mixing can cause the muffins to be dry, tough or misshapen. and The batter should be visibly lumpy, and you may see pockets of dry flour. That's OK! It's extremely important not to overmix the batter, or the resulting muffins

  • Possible Duplicate: Rubbing eggplants in salt I've heard that salting an eggplant (aubergine) before cooking/frying it is necessary not only to reduce the amount of liquid in the result but also to rid the eggplant of some bitterness. I see, online, some support for the claim that the taste of salt removes bitterness, but that would not require pre-salting: one could simply add salt to the dish. And that same Web page also says eggplants on the market generally lack bitterness anyway. On the other hand, various other Web pages (example) matter-of-factly describe pre-salting

  • Based on a related question, some of us are curious about surface tension in liquids commonly used in food and drink. There's a table on Wikipedia containing a tantalizing amount of information, including: The surface tension of water decreases from 76 mN/m to 59 mN/m as temperature increases from 0C to 100C. It's 72 mN/m at warm room temperature, 25C. 10% acetic acid (very strong vinegar) has a substantially reduced surface tension (55 mN/m at 30C) Alcohol can strongly reduce surface tension, to 46 mN/m at 11% and 30 mN/m at 40%. A concentrated sucrose syrup (55%) has somewhat higher

  • Possible Duplicate: How long can I store a food in the pantry, refrigerator, or freezer? How much ahead of time could I put this dish together and refrigerate before heating to serve? Should I freeze it if it is going to be longer than one or 2 days? 1 can(14 oz. / 400 gr) artichoke hearts, drained 1 package(8 oz. / 225 gr) cream cheese, softened 1 cup (236 ml) mayonnaise 3/4 cup (180 ml) finely shredded Parmesan cheese 1/3 cup (80 ml) sliced green onions 1 package(8 oz. / 225 gr) flake-style imitation crabmeat, finely chopped Crackers Keebler® Town House® Original Link

  • Possible Duplicate: What should I look for in a good, multi-purpose chef's knife? Hi guys Just wondering what people consider to be the best Cooks knifes you can get? I've been to a couple of shops and a lot of people are saying that you can't go past the Japanese Knifes... Specifically Kikuichi. The one I have had 3 different places try and sell me is the Kikuichi Gold Elite Damascus Gyuto 210mm - http://www.chefknivestogo.com/kigoelsugy21.html So what do people think? Is this a good knife? For the money is there better out there? Cheers Anthony

  • A mille-feuille (or tompouce) is a pastry, consisting of layers of puff pastry with pastry cream in-between (see this if you don't know it). If you buy it in a pastry store, I find that the glazed top is unique for this pastry. Recipes online tell me that it's confectioner sugar and egg whites, but I think it's something else. It's solid, yet soft. You can see your tooth print in it. It's white and sweet. I can't exactly explain how it differs from regular egg white/sugar icing, but in my opinion it does. Does anybody have a clue what I'm talking about? Do you know what's

  • I am trying to mimic Giordano's pizza at home, as stated in part 1 I need to learn how to make both the crust and the SAUCE. I think I can manage the rest... I am looking for advice on how to make a pizza sauce to mimic Giordano's. I can make a 'pretty good' pizza sauce, but I can't seem to get the seasoning quite right to match Giordano's. I would call garlic the most pronounce flavor, but I can't seem to meter the seasonings 'just right'. In my attempts the garlic either overwhelms the flavor or is not as pronounced as I think it should be.

Data information