Do I need to sift flour that is labeled sifted?

cgp
  • Do I need to sift flour that is labeled sifted? cgp

    Is there really an advantage to sifting flour that I bought that was labeled 'sifted'?

  • Maybe!

    Flour is unusually variable in how densely it will settle, so this can make a big difference for some recipes. The purpose of sifting is to make the amount of flour in a given volume reliable. (If you are measuring by weight, you don't need to sift.)

    By moving around the sifted flour, or pouring it from one container into another, you are changing the way it is packed. Therefore, you can easily "unsift" it in the course of normal handling. Proper sifting is done straight into the measuring device.

  • It can't hurt. I wouldn't trust flour that came pre-sifted. Anything will settle during transport.

    Random tip: pulse your dry ingredients in a food processor instead of sifting.

  • Assuming you're baking: Sifting does more than just standardize the density of your flour (which it doesn't even do all that well). Most recipes that call for sifted flour do so because it helps aerate the batter, as well as keeping the flour from clumping and forming lumps. It won't incorporate a large volume of air, but it will bring in lots of microscopic "seed bubbles", which will then provide lots of nucleation points for the leavening to form CO2 bubbles. Without those seed bubbles, you'll get fewer, larger bubbles of leavening, resulting in a different texture. (Creaming sugar into softened butter performs a similar function in many recipes.)

    Also, +1 for hobodave's food processor tip. Or a good whisking in a large bowl will do in a pinch.

  • Ideally your recipe will have the flour by weight, not volume, as you can't reliably tell how much flour you are adding when you measure the flour by volume. You should search for baking recipes on the net that list the flour by weight (good books do this for bread baking; the Bread Bakers Apprentice does this, for example).

    After weighing the flour you should still sift it as this adds air and can help lend lightness to a quick bread or cake.

Tags
baking flour measurements sifting
Related questions and answers
  • Flour for dusting the buttered pan 4 large eggs 1/4 cup No Calorie sugar 1/4 cup wild honey 2 ounces melted I Can't believe it is not butter 1 ounce Peanut vegetable oil 1.25 cups cocoa, sifted 1/4 cup flour, sifted 1/4 cup Oatmeal, finely blended, and sifted/ 1/2 teaspoon kosher salt I also thought of adding blended Cabbage(high fibre) to make more brownies and increase the fiber. Please tell me... of my own: Ingredients for your average Brownie Soft Butter, for greasing the pan Flour, for dusting the buttered pan 4 large eggs 1 cup sugar , sifted 1 cup brown sugar, sifted 8 ounces melted butter

  • How can I cut out the sour taste a bit and make it sweeter? Overall the icing tastes good, I'd just like to tweak it a bit. The recipe I used contains: 2 8-oz packages cream cheese, at room temperature 8 Tbsp. (1 stick) unsalted butter, at room temperature 2 1/2 cups confectioner's sugar, sifted 1 tsp. vanilla extract Pinch of salt

  • I made moon cakes for the first time at the weekend, but rather than the glazed apearance and firm texture they usually have, they sunk in the middle. Without building the dough equivalent of the great wall of china to help keep the filling in, is there another way I can 'reinforce' the walls to stop them sinking? I used this recipe: 300g Low Protein flour 250g Golden syrup 70g Peanut... egg (lightly beaten) Method Mix syrup, peanut oil and Alkaline water and lemon juice together, stir it well. Slowly pour the sifted flour and knead into a fine dough. Cover and rest

  • Most (or even all?) butter found at the grocery store is labeled "sweet cream". Is there a distinction between this and another type of cream, and if so, what is it?

  • (This may be a silly question, but I'll ask anyway since I am curious about this.) We have an older fridge and it has a drawer labeled "snack pan." I'm not sure how to understand "snack" here... meat compartment is colder?) I tried searching Google already, but all I ended up with were pages of replacement parts, repair instructions, and a few spammy links. Sadly, there was nothing truly informative. So here I am.

  • before, and they were labeled "organic". We assumed they were just bad noodles (they tasted somewhat of soggy cardboard), and threw them out. Last night, I was trying to make udon once again, from... additive that is omitted? I don't have another package in front of me right now to compare, but my two failed packages only contain wheat flour and salt. How could that be wrong? Could the age...A few weeks ago, I had a very strange experience making udon noodles. Almost instantly after adding the dried noodles to boiling water, and giving a slight stir, they began to break apart. After

  • The other day I ventured into a grocery store that sold a lot of root vegetables that I have never seen before. One of the vegetables was a large round thing, and when I poked it, grey 'smoke' came out of it, like one of those mushrooms you stepped on as a kid. None of the vegetables were labeled, so I don't know its name. Does anyone know if such a thing exists, and what does one do with it?

  • So, last time I made gumbo, I got the veggies chopped (onion, celery, green pepper, and garlic) and then realized I had prepped twice as much as I needed. I froze the extra ingredients, labeled for future use for gumbo. I'm making it again now, and it's pretty flavorless. (See below for exactly what I've done.) Since the last time I made it was over a month ago, I don't recall exactly whether... could/should I add more flavor to the current batch? Process: Heat 1.5 TB oil, add 1.5 TB flour to make a dark brown roux. If I were using fresh veggies, I'd add them next. Instead, I held off. Add

  • Texas, where poblanos are commonly found in grocery stores. I moved to California a while back, and here they're still pretty easy to find, but they're always labeled "pasilla". Even at a local produce market with a decent amount of Mexican food (and Spanish-speaking employees) - and just recently I noticed they even have anchos (dried poblanos) labeled as "dried pasillas". I did manage to find one local Mexican restaurant menu online describing a chile relleno as a stuffed poblano, but otherwise it seems pretty universal. So where did this come from? Via the above-linked wikipedia article, I did

Data information