Is there really a difference by throwing the vanilla pod in as well?

  • Is there really a difference by throwing the vanilla pod in as well? Mien

    Recipes with milk and/or cream (panna cotta, ice cream, pastry cream, ...) often ask for the seeds of a vanilla pod (in Europe at least). A fair proportion of those also mention to throw the pod in the dairy as well. Since I re-use the pod afterwards (for vanilla sugar or vanilla extract), I have to clean them and I don't like to do so.

    Is there a real flavour difference in adding the pod as well, given that you can scrape almost all the seeds out? Do recipes just ask you to do so, because you'd get more seeds in the milk or cream, or does the pod itself give a special flavour?

  • I imagine that they do that because most people won't "clean" and reuse a pod after it's been sitting in dairy (I know I wouldn't). That way they can extract the most vanilla flavor out of the pod that they can, before throwing it away.

  • I think you've answered your question yourself. You use the bean itself to make vanilla sugar, so obviously there is much flavour in it as well and not just in the seeds.

    My experience is that you get much more flavour out of the pod if you let it simmer in warm milk/fluid.

flavor budget-cooking vanilla
Related questions and answers
  • As recipes using vanilla seeds often request the pod to be chucked in the pot, I'm thinking there must be no unappealing flavors in the pod itself. I've seen vanilla pastes for sale but they seem to be a mix of the extract and the seeds. So what about blending up used pods with a bit of liquid (vodka?)? Tasteless?

  • I am extremely bad at getting the seeds out of my vanilla beans. So I started putting the "used" beans (which still have at least 1/3 of their seeds) in a small jar with some vodka, and using the liquid as "neverending vanilla extract". There are recipes for vanilla extract out there, but they assume that one would put an exact amount of vanilla beans and vodka together once, then wait, so they give a single ratio. I can't meet this ratio always, but I want to know what the acceptable range is. So: what is the lower bound of vanilla per ml of vodka so that below that bound, the extract

  • This question has answers which explain the difference between vanilla essence and vanilla extract, and which tell you when you may want one over the other - if I am correct in thinking that "vanilla essence" is the same as "vanilla flavouring"? My question is - in baking where colour is not an issue, how do I substitute one for the other? For example in a recipe that asked for 1tsp of extract, how much essence would I use in it's place?

  • I've been having a hankering for Rita's ice cream because I love frozen custard. It's so much richer than vanilla ice cream. I've decided to try to make it myself with this recipe. I have the Cuisinart ice cream maker to mix it in. I'd like to make a big batch (quarts or gallon size would be good) of it can anyone recommend good storage containers? I would like one with a lid because I wouldn't want the custard to smell like "freezer" or get frozen crystals on top. Any tips or suggestions? Thanks! Comments for other frozen custard recipes you've liked would be awesome too if you know of any! :)

  • I can't count the times I have heard that vanilla brings out the flavour of other foods. For example it "makes chocolate taste more chocolatey," etc... I have also heard that it's the only spice that does this (enhance the flavour of other spices/foods). Is this true? If so, by what mechanism does it do this? Here are some places online that mention this alleged property of vanilla without...' to flavorless seasonal fruits or other foods that need a flavor boost. Did you know that chocolate by itself tastes 'flat' which is why it usually contains vanilla?" ( ...Chocolate simply

  • -and-half cream -- (used UK double cream) 5 egg yolks , seperated slightly beaten save whites for Meringue 1/4 cup butter , sliced up 2 teaspoons vanilla extract I followed the instructions (I.... I tried just whisking the lot, but it refused to recombine, so I poured off the oil. The remaining substance (with a little oil) whisked fine when reheated slightly, so I added the butter and vanilla... heat and cook and whisk for an additional 2 minutes. Remove from heat and whisk in butter and vanilla till well mixed. Let cool a bit, whisk and pour into pie shell and set aside. Just after

  • Yesterday I made vanilla sauce to go with an apple pie. I used about 2 dl milk, 3 egg yolks and some sugar. I whisked it in a double boiler maybe too vigourously, because there were tiny bubbles of air in the finished sauce. It reached to correct consistency and otherwise was completely fine, but I would think vanilla sauce should have a relatively thick, rich consistency without any bubbles in it. How can I do it better next time? Would heavy cream help? Should I not use a whisk and just stir with a spoon? How big of a risk is it that my sauce will curdle if I don't use a whisk?

  • seams more right to me, but I don't own a NO2 dispenser: A bit discouraged I just tried to whip milk to get some kind of cream (yes yes I know about whipping cream ;-) ), add some maple syrup and gelatine. Of course this didn't work out really well. Because the recipe also uses vanilla beans I thought about bringing the milk to the boil... my hands on really: Maple foam. The recipe says it consists of milk, maple syrup, gelatine and vanilla beans. I got all the ingredients, but before I tried anything I Googled, thinking

  • It happens a lot with vanilla flavored soy milk - the congealed portions sit at the bottom of the container and looks like whip cream - does this mean that it's going bad?

Data information