Tomato pasta sauce splits. Why?

Gayathri
  • Tomato pasta sauce splits. Why? Gayathri

    I use fresh tomato puree to make my pasta sauce, other things in my sauce are olive oil, garlic, some herbs and salt, i don't let it boil but during the simmering & thickening process the sauce always splits. What am I doing wrong?

  • If by "fresh tomato paste" you mean you're starting with raw tomatoes, that's probably your issue. Most tomatoes you grow in your garden or buy from the store are salad tomatoes - they're not meant for cooking, and will result in a watery sauce like you describe.

    You want a "sauce" tomato. Roma tomatoes or almost any plum-shaped tomato work well. There are others, but they're harder to find.

  • A basic puree of nothing but fresh tomatoes is a simple suspension -- solid particles floating in a liquid substrate. Over time those solids will settle out, leaving a clumpy solid layer and a watery liquid layer. Adding more water (e.g., from pasta water or incompletely wilted onions) will accelerate the trend. To avoid this result, you have a few options:

    1. Remove the water upfront. Before you start cooking, place a large strainer over a large container, line the strainer with a double layer of cheesecloth, and fasten the cheesecloth to the strainer with clips. Pour the tomato puree into the strainer and refrigerate 20-30 minutes, stirring once or twice. If the strainer isn't big enough to hold all of your puree, do it in batches. Alternatively, you can simmer the sauce for a while, until it reaches your desired level of thickness.
    2. Create an emulsion. Essentially, you are binding up the water phase with fat using something like egg yolks or whipping cream. Check out recipes for "alla vodka" sauce or "tomato alfredo" for examples.
    3. Use a starch thickener. This is not my favorite, but again, starch binds up water. There are many ways to do this, such as using bread or tortillas (see: romesco sauce), but you might also see it done in alfredo-like sauces using, say, a starch-based paste like a roux. The theory behind adding pasta water is that the bloomed starch from the pasta itself will help bind up the sauce. The thing is, if you boil your pasta in plenty of water (to avoid boil-over), there won't be enough starch in the water to do the job. Moreover, that starch has already fully hydrated, so its ability to thicken a sauce will be very limited at best.
    4. Reduce the proportion of water to solids. Tomato paste will absorb a little of the water released by the puree. This strategy will only work at the margin, however, unless you add enough paste to overwhelm the flavor of the fresh puree.

    (Edit: I'm assuming you are using only a tiny amount of olive oil to sweat your garlic, such that you are not talking about having an oil slick over your sauce. If that's the problem, the answer is trivially simple: use less oil!)

Related questions and answers
  • . Salting the pasta water. I've learned this trick some time ago and it has been critical to producing the best-tasting pasta. I really want the pasta to be the point of the dish, with the sauce an accompaniment, and the getting salt in the water from the start is the way I get the best flavor in my pasta. In fact, I find that salting the water quite generously works very well as long as I am fulling draining the pasta after boiling. Adding starchy pasta water to my sauce. The starchy water really brings everything together. You could say it thickens it, but not like a roux, as some have

  • Possible Duplicate: How can I keep pasta from sticking to itself? We have a spaghetti dinner at our church and the problem is is that we don't mix it in with sauce because some don't want sauce others don't want a lot of sauce some do. So my question is after I cook the pasta I put it in a colander to drain and it sets till ready to put in hotel pan on the steam table, however by then it's stuck together, how can I keep this from happening or how do I keep it from happening?

  • Recently I made a simple tomato sauce using canned tomatoes. In the recipe it said to first put the tomatoes in the pan, then the juice. I followed this advice and the sauce was great, but will the sauce turn out great again even if I put tomatoes & juice in the pan at the same time? Does it make a difference putting the juice into the pan after the tomatoes? If you need more information, this is the recipe I used.

  • Possible Duplicate: How long does cooked pasta last in the fridge? I work Monday to Friday, and dont pack very good lunches, I recently bought a bunch of pasta and sauce, my plan is to make 5 days worth of pasta for lunches on Sunday night and keep it all in the fridge and bring one portion for lunch each day, will my pasta still taste fine for my Thursday and Friday lunch?

  • I was looking for a recipe for an Italian tomato sauce when I came across an old cookbook from an American Creole Chef I like, but I'm really confused about the terminology he uses for some of the ingredients and wondered if someone could clarify exactly what he's referring to. In the recipe he asks for - 2 cans (6 ounces) of tomato paste 2 cans (10 3/4 ounces) of tomato sauce 2 cans (10 3/4 ounces) of tomato puree I've always assumed that tomato paste and tomato puree were the same thing, but clearly not. Can anyone clarify the difference between these two? Tomato sauce in the UK

  • and then frying them. Will that help? Otherwise what can I add to increase its taste? Thanks. Edit : Instead of having pasta with this sauce, can I have Ciabatta baked in the oven with it? ...I am thinking of making dinner tonight (probably pasta) and the ingredients that I have a courgettes, tomatoes and half a butternut squash. I am 70% vegetarian I first added olive oil, then fried onions and garlic, then added in the vegetables. I added in salt, pepper, souvlaki seasoning, sage and thyme I believe for extra taste. At the end I mixed in a tablespoon of Ricotta (my favourite cheese

  • Possible Duplicate: Why are there so many different pasta shapes? What makes a pasta shape pair with a sauce? When getting ingredients for a soup recipe, I couldn't find the type of pasta the recipe called, so I just bought a spiral type pasta. It seemed to work fine in the recipe, but it got me thinking about pasta. Forgive my ignorance, but it seems like most pastas taste the same. The only thing that seems to make them unique is there size and shape; Is there any reason I should use one pasta over another if it is relatively the same size as the type of pasta a recipe

  • I have a package of frozen precooked Italian meatballs. I got a can of tomato sauce. I would like to cook the meatballs in a tomato sauce. I don't have a pot right now. I only have a 4-cup rice cooker with tow modes: 'cook' and 'warm'. How can I use it? For how long?

  • , my bolognese recipe minus the meat. I mixed my pasta into the sauce a couple minutes before serving. Today I have plenty of leftovers (that have been sitting in the fridge for about 24 hours... and mixing it in work well? Is there something I should add to my meat to better incorporate it into my sauce? Also, I'm not sure if putting the sauce back on heat will be the greatest idea because the pasta...Yesterday I was cooking for someone and was planning on making a bolognese sauce, but when it came to start cooking (ie. after doing my mise en place), she asked if I could leave the meat out

Data information