Why didn't my lemon tart set?

  • Why didn't my lemon tart set? talon8

    I am using this Smitten Kitchen recipe for lemon tarts.

    I made it a few times prior (all within the last few weeks) and it worked beautifully. I loved it because it had a great balance of lemon flavour, to sweetness. The main selling point, however, was the 5 minute prep time.

    In my most recent attempt, I made the pie as before - followed the directions pretty closely.

    However, this time, the pie did not set. The top was caramelized nicely (I probably left it in longer than I did previous times, about 40 minutes?), but inside the pie was almost completely liquid. I have an analog oven thermometer as well, so I know my temperature was fairly accurate.

    I don't do a lot of baking, so I was sure to follow the recipe pretty accurately. The only thing I changed in all three attempts, was I added an extra half lemon's worth of zest. Is there anything I may have missed that may have caused the tart to not set?

    How can I ensure consistent results?

    Note: On the first success I used large eggs, the second success was made with medium eggs. The failed attempt was used with the same batch of medium eggs. Not sure if that's relevant, since we used the same eggs. I wouldn't have thought it'd make a difference, other than the fact that they've been in our fridge an extra week or two.

  • An analogue thermometer isn't too accurate. Besides, it sounds like you measured the oven temperature, not the tart filling. So I suspect that it was the heat after all.

    A custard with both eggs and starch needs to be thoroughly cooked. The reason is that yolks contain an enzyme which liquidifies starch. It doesn't happen outright, but will happen while your tart is cooling. The only way to prevent it is to heat the mix high enough so the enzyme is deactivated.

    To quote On Food And Cooking,

    However, the survival of yolk amylase can spell disaster in the fillings for American cream pies, which are often made in the fashion of a bouillie rather than a pastry cream, and are held for hours or days before serving, enough time for a perfect cream pie to disintegrate into a soupy mess. No matter what a recipe may say, always be sure that the egg yolks in a starch-filled pie filling are heated all the way to the boil.

baking dessert lemon acidity tart
Related questions and answers
  • off the pies gently, got rid of that problem. This is the first time that I have had such a monumental departure from a recipe I have been following (probably luck so far). But can anyone see anything wrong with either the recipe / instructions or suggest what I have did wrong. ...I was making a butterscotch pie for the weekend, by following a recipe from the net. The ingredient list was 1 cup dark brown sugar 1/4 cup cornstarch 1/4 teaspoon salt 4 cups half

  • , it just says to cover (I used plastic wrap). The original recipe says to refrigerate in an ice-water bath; the collection recipe does not (I just put the dish in the fridge). Other issues that may have..., the second one (after agar) being vanilla. I'm not sure whether this is normal or whether it might have been diluting the agar mix. I did notice that it did not seem to be gelling at all while...I don't normally make a lot of confections but decided recently to try a few new things. Yesterday I used this recipe for Turkish delight which I originally found on the Hydrocolloid Recipe

  • ' or 'tsp') dessert spoon (UK) is 10 mL (although may have historically been closer to 15mL) tablespoon (US,CA) is roughly 15 mL (note: abbreviated 'T', 'TB', or 'tbsp') but a tablespoon (UK) is 17.7mL... that Canada may be difficult to classify, as some regions (especially near the southern border) use US terms, while others may use UK terms. It's a community wiki, so feel free to edit and clarify or add additional items. The comments are getting long, so use answers for discussion of specific concepts if necessary. If you're not sure what a term means, ask it as a new question and tag

  • I'm trying to modify a recipe for a cake which calls for 3 cups of shredded butter nut squash. I thought I could replace this with roughly the same amount of pureed pumpkin (like what you would get in a jar). However, the cake is still moist inside, after more than doubling the baking time it originally called for. I don't mind that the consistency is too wet, I'm only concerned about cooking the eggs enough. Unfortunately, I don't have a thermometer to test the internal temperature. Is it safe to assume that at 350 degrees F, with the cake baking for more than 2 hours, that it reached

  • bread I know of which is kneaded in oil instead of flour to prevent sticking). A typical recipe is: 1 kg flour [assume all purpose] 55 g live yeast 300 g white sugar 250 g milk [can be partially or wholly substituted for cream] 250 g butter 8 eggs lemon rind, zests vanilla extract 1 tbsp rum yolk for glazing raisins (optional) almonds (optional) I am not very good at getting it this way, because there is at least a year between each of my tries, meaning that I don't remember what I did when it went good and when it went wrong. My grandma and all of her friends love to give "surefire

  • uniform, and the inside of the bag showed collapsed runny whites all over. It was more foamy than creamy. Where did I screw up this time around? Was the runnyness halfway through a warning sign? I..., and it did collapse a little back to that runny stage, but not nearly as bad as the previous attempt. Another few minutes and I got them back, and then added the splenda and vanilla. I made quenelles... it returned to a runny goop phase, still foamy but no peaks. Two more minutes of beating and it seemed good again, uniformly small bubbles and medium peaks. I stopped here so I wouldn't repeat my previous

  • Three months ago I moved to a new apartment. In my old apartment with my old oven, my baked goods turned out pretty well. However, since I moved, my baked goods vary from almost-good to throw-it-in-the-garbage instantly. First I thought I had to get used to the new oven, so I made adjustments to the temperature and so on. Still I just get very sad every time. The oven is over 30 years old, so I... be appropriate for making pastry It will be used a lot (almost every day), so for home-use it will be used pretty intensely I can not install a built-in oven; I rent this apartment and may not change

  • I have baked baguettes a few times, the recipe I used was something from the net which might or might not be good. It went like this: 13 dl wheat flour 5 dl clean, cold water salt, some olive oil Mix, knead, allow the bread to rise to double size in a cool environment. Bake at 275 C. Now, the first time I made this, I was surprised how well it went. Pretty decent crust, hard but not burnt, easily done and so forth. I noticed however that after a short while the crust was soft. I stored it in plastic bags. The second time I did it, which to me was very consistent with my first

  • broken (I left off the nuts because I was pretty sure it was ruined - the nuts tossed in spices made a lovely alternate snack instead). I notice several comments having similar issues, but also many more saying "It worked perfectly the first time!" What did I do wrong? Should I use a different recipe? Is there some way to make this more foolproof? One of my friends started babbling about "invert syrup" being the cure for my ills... Recipe is at http://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/alton-brown/peanut-brittle-recipe/index.html . My attempt was done in spring in Manchester, UK, so while it may have

Data information