What differences are there between Chia and Flax Eggs?

mfg
  • What differences are there between Chia and Flax Eggs? mfg

    In substituting Flax Eggs (milled/ground flax seeds in a water slurry, after they congeal) for regular eggs, I have found them to be a versatile aide in baking and thickening any number of dishes.

    I have begun to hear tell of using chia seeds instead of flax or something like Ener-G egg replacer. Can chia be used in the same fashion once the seeds are ground as flax?

    • Is the chia composition the same as a flax egg (1 part milled flax seed to 3 parts water, in slurry)?
    • Do they set the same, i.e. congeal in the same time?
    • Can they be mixed for super supplement-y egg substitutes?
    • What differences are there in how you make or use them, and which is preferred for different uses (if either)?

  • With flax seeds I like using 1T of seed (ends up being 2.5T of powder) to 3T of water, and use it for thing that are suppose to be light like cake or something that needs a nutty flavor.

    But with chia seeds I use exactly 1T of powder to 3T of water (ends up looking like egg whites) and use it in brownies, cookies and so on. Also chia doesn't add flavor like flax does.

    **For me chia is definitely stronger.

    The first time I used a chia egg I thought it was like a flax (1T seed = 2.5T powder) but I was wrong, my baked good came out very dense in the middle and tasted raw. You can still use a chia but you have to be exact.

    Also a chia egg will become very thick and gloppy once it's mixed with water whereas a flax just get gooey.

Tags
eggs vegetarian vegan flax chia
Related questions and answers
  • When I'm looking up egg substitutes, one of the easiest (for me) is making a slurry of flax seeds and water. However, I noticed there is a difference between using the flax seeds whole and breaking them up. The slurry is thicker if the seeds aren't whole. Or at least, that's what I think I observe. So, should you only used broken or whole flax seeds, when using them as an egg substitute? Are there (dis)advantages of using flax seeds whole vs. broken up? I've seen this question, that mentions to break them up, but it isn't specifically about substituting eggs. Note: I can imagine it also

  • laminate, but I am looking for vegan solutions)? I have done similar things with egg wash before, would a wash of flax/Chia egg produce the same result? melting something like cheese on the inside... is throwing off my search results, I am guessing perhaps there is a molten cup cake batter/dough recipe or something that can be modified to have a savory corn-bread flavor and still really stand up to baking... bread puck, and bake until it is molten and exterior browns. Standard style corn breads I have eaten are too spongy for this kind of application, and would not be able to be pressed against the walls

  • I am thinking about incorporating some raw shredded beets in a vegan chocolate sheet cake. Since it is vegan, I will be substituting with Ener-G, chia, or flax egg substitutes and earth balance margarine, and can add more if a solution so dictates. In other baking, I have not found any need to make drastic accomodations to accommodate for moisture or texture. However, I am wondering... like to know so that I can adjust the recipe accordingly. If so please include any tips to balance it out, bearing in mind that extra egg substitute or margarine is doable, but not if it entails one

  • I made a pretty simple and easy hamantaschen recipe last night, and it came out really well. The only substitution I made was to flex 3 eggs for 3 tablespoons milled, gelled flax seed in 9 tablespoons water. I am essentially unfamiliar with the dough, and wasn't sure what to expect. It had a great crumb, shortbread texture, but I ran into the dough unfolding/unpinching while baking. The dough...? Is the amount of baking powder appropriate? The recipe didn't call for any salt, but I added some for flavor; could this have been problematic in causing over-rising? The flax egg substitution would have had

  • with mac 'n cheese So what direction would, at least in theory, provide a denser, more cohesive solid, and allow for some browning, though not complete? (The browning will be finished off by egg-wash...This is basically the first loaf I have baked and I am having difficulty knowing how I should tweak it. I have four directions to go with it and would like to know in which direction I should go..., and turn into a solid, cohesive whole. I have two primary forks from my first test. Test #1: 325'f @ 45min browned slightly on bottom and sides after 45 minutes; too loose, not browned raised

  • I need to replace the grill grates on my Weber Genesis grill, and I see that I can get either enameled porcelain (like I already have) or upgrade to stainless steel. A few concerns spring to mind when considering the upgrade: Are there any differences between the two other than appearance? Does one hold heat better than the other? What differences are there to the grates' maintenance/upkeep/cleaning/appearance?

  • it with language) Also see What international cooking terms sound similar but have different meanings? for similar issues with other languages. Vegetables: Eggplant (US, AU) is an aubergine (UK). Zucchini (US...), Scallions (US), and green onions may not always be the same thing, but can typically be substituted for each other. (more details). Herbs, Spices & Seasonings: Kosher(ing) salt (US) is flaked... baking powder in it, it does not have fat in it such as Bisquick or other 'baking mixes'. wholemeal flour (UK) is whole wheat flour (US) Meats: Ground beef (US) is minced beef (AU, UK) or simply

  • , but not unbearably so. Most of the heat was in my throat, not in my mouth (mostly as an aftertaste), and I did have that bitter aftertaste Can something be wrong with my batch of cayenne peper? Or is this how... 14 oz can of chopped tomatoes 1 12 oz bottle of beer 2 tsp sugar 1 1/2 tsp ground cumin 1 1/2 tsp cayenne peper 1 tsp red peper flakes 2 tsp Tabasco 1 tsp dried oregano 1 tsp smoked paprika 1/2 tsp garlic powder 1 tsp crushed coriander seeds 2 tsp Worchestershire sauce 1 can of cooked red kidney beans (drained and rinsed) The method was, basically: Saute onions and pepers for approx 5

  • I made moon cakes for the first time at the weekend, but rather than the glazed apearance and firm texture they usually have, they sunk in the middle. Without building the dough equivalent of the great wall of china to help keep the filling in, is there another way I can 'reinforce' the walls to stop them sinking? I used this recipe: 300g Low Protein flour 250g Golden syrup 70g Peanut oil 1/2tsp Alkaline water 1/8 Lemon juice from a whole lemon Lotus paste Pandan paste Steamed Salted Egg Yolk (Steamed 10 mins under high heat) Egg wash - 2 egg yolk plus 1 whole

Data information