Is wheat gluten (wheat protein) an acceptible cooking substitute for soy protein powder or rice protein powder?

STW
  • Is wheat gluten (wheat protein) an acceptible cooking substitute for soy protein powder or rice protein powder? STW

    I'm trying a handful of vegan dishes, and have found a broth recipe which requires a small amount of soy or rice protein powder (1Tbsp). This eventually makes 30 cups of broth, so overall is a very small component.

    I have wheat gluten available, and am wondering if it would be an acceptible substitute; or if I would be better off leaving it out altogether, or with another substitute (presuming the protein is used to slightly thicken the broth, would corn starch be a 1:1 substitution)?

    Full recipe here

  • Vital wheat gluten will not dissolve as those two isolates will. Vital what gluten would likelier clot. Here its a description of the difference between soy flour and soy protein isolate; although VWG is basically a protein isolate (it is the leftover from washing away the starch in wheat), like those powders, the other two are gluten free. However, like with any flour, you can use it as a slurry to avoid this problem

Tags
substitutions vegetarian vegan vital-wheat-gluten
Related questions and answers
  • I've always thought that the rule of thumb for adding vital wheat gluten to a bread recipe was to add one tablespoon of it per cup of flour called for. A friend is telling me that rather than do that, I should count the vital wheat gluten as flour, and for every tablespoon of it that I add to the recipe, I should subtract a tablespoon of flour from the recipe. Which of us is correct and why? The bread recipe that I'm following calls for 3 1/2 cups of whole wheat flour and 1/4 cup of dried, nonfat milk powder. I don't have the milk powder, so I thought that the vital wheat gluten would make

  • I tried my hand at making homemade seitan the other night, and it was pretty good - my only complaint was that it wasn't as firm as I would have liked it to be. These are the steps I followed (based on "Basic Seitan Recipie" instructions on the back of a vital wheat gluten box) Mixed vital wheat gluten with water, kneaded for 5 minutes until it was elastic. Formed into 2.5" log, let sit for 5 minutes. Cut log into 0.5" pieces. Heated vegetable broth over medium flame, added seitan pieces. Brought broth to a boil. Reduced flame, let seitan simmer for 1 hour, stirring occasionally. So what

  • I am going to try to make gluten-free pizza for my wife, and I'm going to start with this Serious Eats recipe. The recipe calls for white rice flour, but my wife has just about everything EXCEPT that. She has: corn, oat, potato, rye, sorghum, soy, and tapioca flours. Which of these (if any) can I substitute for white rice flour? Or should I just go out and buy some? For posterity, the recipe is: 1 (7.5 ounce) package Chebe Original Bread Mix (not Pizza Mix) 1 cup white rice flour 1 teaspoon baking powder 1 teaspoon salt 3/4 cup water plus an additional tablespoon or two, if needed

  • until tender the vegetables were removed and the resulting broth cooked until thick and used as a glace. My question is, what could I do to be able to cook this if I don't have Parmesan. As the dish does have a strong flavour on its own I think it would be OK but is there perhaps something (nondairy, non-meat, not from a special shop) I could substitute with? I am concerned with what would...I've used a recipe before (can't find it anymore, sorry) where I steamed sticks of celery root. The ingredients I remember are garlic (whole cloves steamed together with the celery), probably a small

  • I've been making pizza dough for years, and recently found that I have a gluten allergy, and can no longer eat wheat flour! Very sad news, indeed. So... I bought Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Pizza dough mix, which has a bit of xantham gum in it, and serval kinds of flour (rice flour, tapioca, flour, corn flour, etc). The dough itself was difficult to work with, a bit crumbly, and not as stretchy as I would like. I know that the "stretch" I'm talking about truly come from gluten, but is there anything I can add, to help with the consistency? The flavor was perfect, and the calzones were

  • I like making veggie burgers, and one recipe that I use relies on vital wheat gluten (as well as egg replacer) to have a coherent burger. Here are the ingredients for one particular burger: 1 cup TVP ¾ cup Vegetable broth 2 tbsp. Tamari 2 tbsp. Teriyaki Sauce 1 egg Egg replacer 1 cup Crushed pineapple 2 tbsp. Brown sugar ½ cup Vital wheat gluten ½ cup Whole wheat flour... has an excellent texture, but the inside of the burger is very rubbery, being that it's practically raw and the gluten has that rubbery texture to it. If I pan fry the burgers much longer, they turn

  • I normally make my Swedish pancakes with soy milk because my SO has a dairy sensitivity. But today I used cow's milk, and I noticed that my pancakes seemed to brown a lot faster than they usually do, resulting in an unattractive dark brown shade. Is there anything to this, or was I imagining things? (I checked out this question, which pertains to baking, and this question, which focuses on pasta and mashed potatoes, but I figure that pancakes/crepes might have a slightly different answer.)

  • that are already a mix) Wheat germ A bit of chocolate whey protein (the kind bodybuilders use) Unsalted whole peanuts I just mixed them with honey and milk, spread them to even thickness (around 1 inch?) on top of a baking sheet, and put them in the food dehydrator for said 3-4 hours. The taste turned out OK (it seems to have lost some sweetness from dehydration?) but it's not crunchy enough. Would leaving it on the dehydrator (on the highest heat) longer do the trick for making it crunchy, or would I have to use the oven no matter what?

  • Does anybody have any data on the nutritional composition of chicken broth (liquid in chicken soup) and chicken stock (liquid from chicken bones)? For example, will stock contain more protein then broth? Have googled the nutritional contents I read conflicting things and I'm not sure whether they are referring to broth or stock. When during the cooking process is protein extracted? If you simmer stock for 2-8 hours, does most of it come out in the first two hours, or does more come out with prolonged simmering?

Data information