Conversion rule: how to switch oil and butter?

Mien
  • Conversion rule: how to switch oil and butter? Mien

    Just a moment ago, I was making muffins. The recipe calls for 125ml oil.
    As a footnote, it says that you can replace the oil with 125g butter.

    Can you do so in every recipe (not just muffins or pastry)?

    I've found this, but the amounts aren't the same (while my recipe says to use the same amount).

  • Butter and cooking oil are not interchangeable in every recipe.

    • Butter actually has water in it, while oil is a pure lipid. This can cause problems with water-sensitive preparations, for example a choux paste (where the proper ratio of water to flour is extremely important) or anything using melted chocolate (where the water in butter can cause it to seize).

    • Butter can also be whipped; oil definitely cannot (except coconut oil). You normally wouldn't use olive or sunflower oil in, for example, an icing.

    • Butter is a solid at room temperature, while oil is a liquid. When making something that needs to be relatively solid - for example, bread or pie dough or anything requiring a beurre manié - you do not want to substitute butter for oil. Shortening is a better substitute.

    • Butter has a much lower smoke point and will scorch at temperatures that oils are often subjected to. You have to be very careful when frying anything in butter, and you'll need to watch carefully if baking with butter at very high temperatures.

    You have to understand the recipe you are making if you want to know how to do the conversion (or if a conversion is even possible). If the recipe is fat-dependent, you need to use more butter than oil. If it is water-dependent, you generally should use less butter. If it is both, you likely can't do a direct substitution and will have to add or remove something else. And if the recipe relies on the solid/liquid state of the fat, then you simply cannot substitute.

    Muffins just happen to be one of those things where it really doesn't matter much. Like all quickbreads, you can vary the amount of fat substantially and all it will do is change the texture of the final dish; quickbreads with more fat tend to be richer, more moist, and less dense. The Joy of Cooking recipe for waffle batter recommends anywhere from 1/4 cup to 1 cup of butter, which is a pretty wide margin of error; in recipes like that, you can usually play fast and loose with the substitutions.

Related questions and answers
  • the last remove from heat and just before whisking in the butter, I needed a call of nature. When I got back the mixture had separated into what looked like curdled milk and an oily fat like substance. I tried just whisking the lot, but it refused to recombine, so I poured off the oil. The remaining substance (with a little oil) whisked fine when reheated slightly, so I added the butter and vanilla... off the pies gently, got rid of that problem. This is the first time that I have had such a monumental departure from a recipe I have been following (probably luck so far). But can anyone see

  • When baking muffins and adding the liquid ingredients to the "well" in the dry ingredients, the recipe says "to just combine". Does this mean not to add the whole liquid mixture, only enough to wet the dry ingredients?

  • Larousse De La Cuisine (American Edition) has the following recipe for vichyssoise: 250g leeks 250g potatos 50g butter 1.75L water 200mL crème fraîche I was cooking 3 times as much soup, so I multiplied the amount of leeks, potatos, and butter by 3. However, 5.25L was just way too much. I ended up eyeballing it and using ~3L. Still, the end result was a bit too watery for me. It seems that even the above recipe has too much water. Is this a typo? Or was it in the scaling up? I can imagine that you do not simply multiply by 3, even if you use a bigger pot than you'd use for the non

  • I tried this recipe with good results. http://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/ina-garten/blueberry-coffee-cake-muffins-recipe/index.html So I decided to make plain vanilla muffins using the same recipe except for adding blueberries. However, the texture was not the same - I am guessing this is because of the reduced moisture content from the missing blueberries. Can someone please guide me as to what I should modify to make up for the reduced moisture (assuming that is the cause)? Many thanks

  • So I just tried this recipe for banana muffins. They taste great (even directly after baking) and the texture is really nice and soft - like a muffin is supposed to be. The problem: They don't rise...? The accepted answer has many great hints, but I truly don't believe any of these points target my problem. I thought that I maybe didn't fill the forms enough, but the recipe is for 12 muffins and I made...: Ok, so here is the recipe: 180 g flour (I used Type 550 wheat flour) 120 g brown sugar 1 teaspoon baking powder 1 teaspoon baking soda a pinch of salt 75 g melted butter 4 ripe mashed bananas 1 egg

  • is the amount of gelatin I guess. The recipe says to use 5 sheets, so I used 5 sheets. On the package it says that 6 sheets are needed to thicken 500 ml liquid. As I have used 350 ml heavy cream an 250 ml...Yesterday I tried to make Bavarian Cream for the first time - it was a disaster. I think I know where I went wrong, but maybe someone with a bit of experience can still help me out. So I got this recipe consisting of some egg yolks, sugar, gelatin, milk, heavy cream and some oil, syrup or liquor for flavor. The recipe states to whisk the yolks together with the sugar until the mixture is pale

  • Is there something that I can use as a substitute for vegetable oil in a recipe? I'm actually making cornbread (I think it matters), and normally the recipe calls for 1/3 cup vegetable oil. Unfortunately I just realized that I'm out. Can I use butter or shortening instead? If so, roughly how much would I try?

  • When a recipe (like for muffins) calls for vegetable oil, does it matter if I substitute the oil for butter because I want that buttery taste in the muffins? Do I need to compensate for the difference by adding/subtracting the amount of butter added?

  • I'm planning on making a Swiss roll. This is a sponge cake, baked in your baking sheet (so it's thin) and you roll it up, mostly with a filling. While looking for a recipe, some recipes say to use the same recipe as for a regular sponge cake, but add some melted butter. Other recipes don't mention melted butter and stick to eggs, sugar and flour. I'm wondering what the function of the butter is in a Swiss roll. Does it help with rolling? Or is it just taste? Can I omit it? (I would omit it if it's just the taste. My filling will be butter cream.)

Data information